93011 - History of Religions: Objects and Heritages (1) (LM)

Course contents

Fetishes, objects of affection and ‘sacred’ objects

Starting with the definition of material culture, the aim of this course is to address the notions of instrumentality and expressivity in ‘religious’ objects, and to discuss how these are treasured and patrimonialized. By analyzing objects it is possible to reinterpret some of the main issues involved in the history of religions, such as sacred/profane, belief/ritual, and affection/devotion.

Attending students will be involved in research activities starting with the observation of real data, which will provide the basis for specific theoretical reflection. Students will be asked to carry out activities to acquire basic research skills related to fieldwork.

More specifically, students can decide to engage in a small fieldwork experience (recommended, but not compulsory) focusing on some objects of common use at home and writing two analytical papers (5-7 pages each). The papers should deal with an analysis of the object in analytical-descriptive terms and a discussion from a devotional perspective and starting with spatiality.

In particular, this fieldwork ethnographic study entails the following:

1. Finding and selecting an object for everyday use at home;
2. Writing a paper, including some pictures, to describe the object, its location, the surrounding space, and its use value (essay 1);
3. Proposing a new exhibition of the object with a plan of a new setting, still inside one’s home, from a devotional perspective and with value attribution;
4. Writing a paper to critically discuss the exhibition choice (including pictures), with a description of spatiality, the relation between objects, the semantic value attributed and the result of the whole operation (essay 2).

The IOL platform will be used in the fieldwork. Should the essays be evaluated positively, they will be taken into account for the final exam.

During the course the following subjects will be addressed:

• history of material culture
• the value of objects in religious field
• objects and relationality
• ‘sacred’ objects
• ‘sacred’ objects and beliefs
• Objects in action
• positioning and exhibition
• cultural objects and assets
• patrimonialization processes

Some of the issues discussed in the course will also be reconsidered by watching the movies: Les dieux objects, Marc Augé, Jean-Paul Colleyn, Jean-Pierre Dozon, Catherine Clippel (2010); On fait les reliques, Francesca Sbardella (2002).

At the end of the course the student shall be able to:

• Collaboratively develop a model to be applied to fieldwork ethno-anthropological research.
• Take advantage of the Internet as a framework enabling self-study and collaborative learning; also knowing the implications of an open, real, and participatory space to develop collaborative writing techniques and strategies online using IOL platform.
• Read, analyze, summarize, understand, and explain explicit and implicit information (in particular scientific papers) on ethnographic theories related to objects.
• Apply fieldwork ethnographic research techniques and develop the necessary skills to collect, process, analyze, and interpret genuine empirical data within a specific setting.
• Recognize and manage the ethnographic variables involved in museum fieldwork research.
• Use different research tools that are necessary to hypothesize an exhibition project.

Readings/Bibliography

Programme for attending students

1) Ugo Fabietti, Materia sacra. Corpi, oggetti, immagini, feticci nella pratica religiosa, Raffaello Cortina, Milano 2014.

2) Augé M., 2002, Il dio oggetto, Roma, Meltemi [tit. or. Le dieu objet, Paris, Flammarion, 1998].

3) Pomian K., Storia culturale, storia dei semiofori, in Che cos’è la storia, Mondadori, Milano 2009, cap. V, pp. 129-155

https://virtuale.unibo.it/course/view.php?id=39055

Programme for non-attending students

1) Ugo Fabietti, Materia sacra. Corpi, oggetti, immagini, feticci nella pratica religiosa, Raffaello Cortina, Milano 2014.

2) Augé M., 2002, Il dio oggetto, Roma, Meltemi [tit. or. Le dieu objet, Paris, Flammarion, 1998].

3) Parbuono D., Sbardella F. (a cura di), Costruzione di patrimoni. Le parole degli oggetti e delle convenzioni, Pàtron, Bologna 2017.

Recommended references

Bartoletti R., La narrazione delle cose. Analisi socio-comunicativa degli oggetti, FrancoAngeli, Milano 2007.

Baudrillard J., Il sistema degli oggetti, Bompiani, Milano 2004.

Caoci A. e Lai F., Gli “oggetti culturali”. L’artigianato tra estetica, antropologia e sviluppo locale, Franco Angeli, Milano 2007.

Cirese A.M., Beni volatili, stili, musei : diciotto altri scritti su oggetti e segni, a cura di Pietro Clemente, Gianfranco Molteni, Gli ori, Prato 2007.

Clemente P., L’antropologia del patrimonio culturale in L.Faldini, E.Pili, a cura di Saperi antropologici, media e società civile nell’Italia contemporanea, Atti del 1 Convegno Nazionale dell’ANUAC, Roma, CISU, 2011, pp. 295 – 317.

Clifford J., “I musei come zone di contatto” in Strade. Viaggio e traduzione alla fine del secolo XX, Bollati Boringhieri, 2008

Douglas M e Isherwood B., Il mondo delle cose, Il mulino, Bologna 1984.

Julien M. P. et Warnier J. P., Approches de la culture matérielle. Corps à corps avec l’objet. L’Harmattan, Paris 1999.

Kopytoff I., La biografia culturale degli oggetti: la mercificazione come processo [1986], pp. 77-111, in Mora E. (curatore), Gli attrezzi per vivere. Forme della produzione culturale tra industria e vita quotidiana, Edizioni di Vita e Pensiero, Milano 2005.

La Cecla, F., Non è cosa. Vita affettiva degli oggetti, Elèuthera. Milano 1998.

Latour B., 2005, Il culto Moderno dei fatticci, Roma, Meltemi [tit. or., Petite réflexion sur le culte moderne des dieux faitiches, Sinthelabo, 1996].

Maffi I. (a cura di), Il patrimonio culturale, Meltemi, Roma 2006.

Miller D., Per un’antropologia delle cose, Ledizioni 2013.

Perec G., Le cose: una storia degli anni Sessanta, Einaudi, Torino 2011

Pomian Krzysztof, 2004, Dalle sacre reliquie all’arte moderna: Venezia-Chicago dal XIII al XX secolo, Milano, Il Saggiatore [tit. or. Des saintes reliques à l’art moderne: Venise-Chicago, XIIIe-XXe siècle, Paris, Gallimard, 2003].

Rheims M., Le vie étrange des objets, Paris, Libraire Plon, Paris 1959

Riccini R., Imparare dalle cose. La cultura materiale nei musei, Clueb, Bologna 2003

Rigotti F., Il pensiero delle cose, Apogero, Milano 2007

Solinas P.G. (a cura di), Gli oggetti esemplari. I documenti di cultura materiale in antropologia, Ed. del Grifo, Montepulciano 1989

Warnier, J. P. La cultura materiale, Meltemi, Roma 2005.

Teaching methods

Traditional lectures will alternate with seminars for in-depth discussion in which students are invited to actively take part with personal investigations, presentations and reports concerning the proposed issues.

For those who accept to take part in the fieldwork assignment, part of the programme will be completed by using UNIBO’s IOL platform: this activity will be based on collaborative writing applied to ethnographic research through the use of collaborative digital tools. In order to familiarize with theory and put it into practice, the students will be asked to write some texts about museological analysis considering a case study.

Assessment methods

The final examination is an interview. The students will be asked some questions concerning the texts included in the syllabus and the subjects presented in them.

For attending students, the assessment of the final interview is complemented with the research report on the fieldwork simulation (for those who may take part in it) and with specific questions on the subjects discussed in class.

Exam reservations should be made via the Almaesami website.

Assessment criteria:

• Teamwork and problem solving skills
• Quantity and quality of each student’s participation on the IOL platform
• Active participation in seminar and class discussion: ability to present, contrast and defend one’s ideas with data that are relevant to the proposed subjects
• In-depth and detailed knowledge of the syllabus texts
• Argument and critical skills
• Language appropriateness
• The evaluation of the written report will consider the typical conventions of academic writing (orthography, layout, and presentation), and also the ability to ponder, analyze, and draw conclusions.

Teaching tools

Multimedia tools will be used, e.g. audio recordings and videos. For some fieldwork activities the students will work in a team and use collaborative digital resources, such as IOL platform.

Slides and Power Point presentations will also be used in some classes.

Office hours

See the website of Francesca Sbardella